Dr. Henry Lee Testifies in Robinson Case - News, Weather, Sports, Toledo, OH

Dr. Henry Lee Testifies in Robinson Case

Dr. Henry Lee has helped solve 6,000 cases. Dr. Henry Lee has helped solve 6,000 cases.
Crime scene photo shows altar cloth beside the murdered nun's body. Crime scene photo shows altar cloth beside the murdered nun's body.
Lee testified about a stain that was possibly made by a medallion on this letter opener. Lee testified about a stain that was possibly made by a medallion on this letter opener.
Dr. Lee on the witness stand. Dr. Lee on the witness stand.

TOLEDO (AP) -- Famed forensic expert, Dr. Henry Lee, testified Thursday at the trial of a priest who's accused of murdering Sister Margaret Ann Pahl on Holy Saturday in 1980. The nun was choked and stabbed 31 times. Two years ago police charged Robinson with murder. Authorities have not disclosed a motive.

Dr. Lee has worked on several high-profile cases over the years, and testified at the murder trial of O.J. Simpson and the rape trial of William Kennedy Smith. Lee also worked on the JonBenet Ramsey murder investigation, and has been involved in more than 6,000 investigations. Both prosecutors and defense attorneys have relied on his expertise.

Lee told jurors that a bloody stain on an altar cloth might link a nun's murder with the priest. Sister Margaret Ann's body was found on the floor of the sacristy of a hospital chapel, along with the bloody altar cloth that Lee examined. Lee said the stain on the altar cloth had similar characteristics to that of a medallion on Father Robinson's letter opener.

Prosecutors say Father Robinson used that letter opener to kill Sister Margaret Ann in the sacristy of a Mercy Hospital chapel. Nearly two weeks after the murder, police found the letter opener in 1980 in the drawer of a desk in Robinson's living quarters at the hospital.

Dr. Lee said that when he examined other stains on the dress Sister Margaret Ann wore, he found inconsistencies between them and the alleged murder weapon.

A dime-sized medallion on the letter opener shows an image of the U.S. Capitol. Dr. Lee pointed at an enlarged photo of a blood stain, drawing the jury's attention to what he said looked like the dome outline of the Capitol. "The size is similar, the shape is similar, the diameter is similar," he said. However, Dr. Lee would not call the stain and the medallion an exact match. "I can only say it is similar," he said.

Paulette Sutton, a nationally-known expert in blood stains, also testified Wednesday that the faint stain showed what looked like the Capitol.

The medallion from the letter opener showed no DNA evidence, said Diane Gehres, a DNA examiner from the state crime lab.

DNA tests on the slain nun's fingernails and underwear were not able to link the priest to the crime scene, expert witnesses have testified. The tests produced trace amounts of DNA, some of which were too small to produce any results, they said.

Megan Shaffer, of ReliaGene Technologies in New Orleans, said she found blood on at least one of the nun's fingernails. She said there was enough DNA to determine that it came from a man other than Robinson. Shaffer said the DNA could have come from shaking hands or someone coughing.

Prosecutors said the trace of DNA was so small that tests showing it came from a man might have been wrong, or the sample could have been left by someone who moved her body after the crime.

Other tests on pieces of the altar cloth contained only Sister Margaret Ann's DNA, Gehres said. Father Robinson was Mercy Hospital's Roman Catholic chaplain at the time of the murder. He worked closely with Sister Margaret Ann, who was the chapel caretaker, and presided over her funeral.

Father Robinson, 68, could get life in prison if convicted of the murder.

Posted by PJS

The Associated Press contributed to this report. 

  • Headlines from Lucas, Wood, Ottawa, Fulton & Monroe CountiesNewsMore>>

  • First Alert Forecast: Dry and comfortable Thursday

    First Alert Forecast: Dry and comfortable Thursday

    Tuesday chances for a few storms will remain but the oppressive heat simmers with highs back into the 80s.

    More >>

    Tuesday chances for a few storms will remain but the oppressive heat simmers with highs back into the 80s.

    More >>
  • Toledo attorneys plan to again challenge red light camera law constitutionality

    Wednesday, June 20 2018 6:13 PM EDT2018-06-20 22:13:35 GMT
    Ohio Supreme Court rules against City of Toledo in red light camera lawsuit (Source: WTOL)Ohio Supreme Court rules against City of Toledo in red light camera lawsuit (Source: WTOL)

    THIS AIRS IN THE A BLOCK OF THE 6 TOLEDO, OH (WTOL) - The Ohio Supreme Court has ruled against the city of Toledo when it comes to the use of red light cameras. But, this doesn’t change the ability for local law enforcement to handout tickets to drivers from this technology. The city of Toledo was challenging a law put in place that reduced the amount of money it got from the state because of the use of these cameras. Just last year, the&...

    More >>

    THIS AIRS IN THE A BLOCK OF THE 6 TOLEDO, OH (WTOL) - The Ohio Supreme Court has ruled against the city of Toledo when it comes to the use of red light cameras. But, this doesn’t change the ability for local law enforcement to handout tickets to drivers from this technology. The ci

    More >>
  • Local mom motivated to organize immigration march

    Local mom motivated to organize immigration march

    Wednesday, June 20 2018 6:03 PM EDT2018-06-20 22:03:11 GMT
    (Mallett says she's happy the President signed the executive order and hopes the move is from the heart. Now, she's hoping for balanced immigration reform.)(Mallett says she's happy the President signed the executive order and hopes the move is from the heart. Now, she's hoping for balanced immigration reform.)
    (Mallett says she's happy the President signed the executive order and hopes the move is from the heart. Now, she's hoping for balanced immigration reform.)(Mallett says she's happy the President signed the executive order and hopes the move is from the heart. Now, she's hoping for balanced immigration reform.)

    For someone who doesn't consider herself as politically active, Ottawa Hill mom, Jessica Mallett said  the separation of children from their families at the border turned human for her.

    More >>

    For someone who doesn't consider herself as politically active, Ottawa Hill mom, Jessica Mallett said  the separation of children from their families at the border turned human for her.

    More >>
Powered by Frankly