The search for answers: Who killed 5-year-old Nevaeh Buchanan? - News, Weather, Sports, Toledo, OH

The search for answers: Who killed 5-year-old Nevaeh Buchanan?

Police believe someone knows who killed 5-year-old Nevaeh Buchanan seven years ago. (Source: WTOL) Police believe someone knows who killed 5-year-old Nevaeh Buchanan seven years ago. (Source: WTOL)
On May 24, 2009, the day before Memorial Day, 7-year-old Nevaeh vanished from a parking lot right outside the Charlotte Arms Apartment complex where she lived. (Source: WTOL) On May 24, 2009, the day before Memorial Day, 7-year-old Nevaeh vanished from a parking lot right outside the Charlotte Arms Apartment complex where she lived. (Source: WTOL)
Nevaeh’s cousin Risa Smith has been searching for answers since the beginning.  (Source: WTOL) Nevaeh’s cousin Risa Smith has been searching for answers since the beginning.  (Source: WTOL)
In May, marchers held signs and chanted 'Justice for Nevaeh'. (Source: WTOL) In May, marchers held signs and chanted 'Justice for Nevaeh'. (Source: WTOL)
  • Special ReportsMore>>

  • The path to a debt-free education? Save early and often

    The path to a debt-free education? Save early and often

    Friday, June 15 2018 6:10 PM EDT2018-06-15 22:10:31 GMT

    Jonathan Sagaser is one of millions of American parents working to send his kids to college. "We had the inspiration to do it early on," he says. Jon and his wife own Sebastiano's Italian restaurant in South Toledo. Their three children, age six, four and two spend a lot of time there as the couple sometimes works 60 to 80 hours a week as small business owners. They plan to pay for half of each of their children's education. "I guess we just want to give them a little b...

    More >>

    Jonathan Sagaser is one of millions of American parents working to send his kids to college. "We had the inspiration to do it early on," he says. Jon and his wife own Sebastiano's Italian restaurant in South Toledo. Their three children, age six, four and two spend a lot of time there as the couple sometimes works 60 to 80 hours a week as small business owners. They plan to pay for half of each of their children's education. "I guess we just want to give them a little b...

    More >>
  • Day tripping: Have an adventure without busting your budget

    Day tripping: Have an adventure without busting your budget

    Tuesday, June 12 2018 10:40 AM EDT2018-06-12 14:40:18 GMT
    (Source: WTOL)(Source: WTOL)

    We're all familiar with our fantastic metroparks, the Toledo Zoo and the Toledo Museum of Art. We have our staples, but if you're up for an adventure this summer, and need to watch your wallet, you need ideas and advice. “The more you can be out and about doing things, the less time they're spending in front of a tablet or a TV,” said Jen Sherwin.  Between nieces and nephews, babysitting, and her own child, Sherwin has finding things to do down to a science.

    More >>

    We're all familiar with our fantastic metroparks, the Toledo Zoo and the Toledo Museum of Art. We have our staples, but if you're up for an adventure this summer, and need to watch your wallet, you need ideas and advice. “The more you can be out and about doing things, the less time they're spending in front of a tablet or a TV,” said Jen Sherwin.  Between nieces and nephews, babysitting, and her own child, Sherwin has finding things to do down to a science.

    More >>
  • Rents with Benefits: How to negotiate a better rent in an owner's market

    Rents with Benefits: How to negotiate a better rent in an owner's market

    Sunday, June 10 2018 6:10 PM EDT2018-06-10 22:10:48 GMT
    The Toledo rental market is tight with more renters looking for a place to live than available units (Source: WTOL)The Toledo rental market is tight with more renters looking for a place to live than available units (Source: WTOL)

    The Toledo rental market is tight. There are fewer units in comparison to demand for them. That makes it an owner’s market.

    More >>

    The Toledo rental market is tight. There are fewer units in comparison to demand for them. That makes it an owner’s market.

    More >>
MONROE COUNTY, MI (WTOL) -

It’s an unsolved murder, with no break in the case. Police believe someone knows who killed 5-year-old Nevaeh Buchanan seven years ago, and any new tips could help finally put a child-murderer behind bars.

“Wow. Seven years ago, we got the call that she was missing,” Nevaeh’s paternal grandmother Carla Nash said.

Nash recalls May 24, 2009, the day before Memorial Day, when her granddaughter vanished from a parking lot right outside the Charlotte Arms Apartment complex where she lived.

Who could’ve taken Nevaeh in broad daylight without anyone noticing? 

“Everybody was in shock, everybody,” Tim Finley said.

Finley said he was visiting his sister at Charlotte Arms the day of Nevaeh’s disappearance. He said he remembers leaving the parking lot around 7 p.m., about the same time Nevaeh went missing.

He said he didn’t see any children playing outside.

“But I did see a little red car speeding out of the back parking lot that night,” Finley said.

About ten days and ten miles from where Nevaeh was last seen, her little body was found buried and covered in cement along the River Raisin.

The emotional wounds are still fresh for Nevaeh’s grandmother.

“That was probably one of the hardest days of my whole life I’ve ever had to face,” Nash said.

Just two weeks ago, the family finally received a copy of Nevaeh’s autopsy report. The report indicates she was possibly buried alive. However, the family said the report did not address whether or not Nevaeh was sexually assaulted.

“I don’t believe that it was a random kidnapping and murder,” said Nash. “I believe that it was someone who knew Nevaeh.”

Back in 2009, two men, George Kennedy, 39, and Roy Lee Smith, 48, both friends of Nevaeh’s mother, were arrested as possible suspects. Both men are registered sex offenders, yet neither was ever formally charged. 

But the family says it is suspicious that the autopsy report didn’t even address if Nevaeh’s body had been evaluated for a sex crime. 

In fact, there haven’t been any updates from law enforcement since 2012.

“I want justice for her,” said Nash. “It’s been seven years; we should have heard something by now.”

WTOL 11 reached out to the Monroe County Sheriff’s office to get an update on Nevaeh’s case and find out if they have any new leads. The Sheriff declined the request for an interview.

Over the phone, a detective said, “We gave an update in 2012. There’s nothing new.”

Nevaeh’s cousin Risa Smith has been searching for answers since the beginning. 

“Why are we the only ones fighting? Why isn’t there more interest? Why isn’t there more information?” Smith said.

She and other supporters created the movement “Justice for Neveah”. The group is offering a $50,000 reward for any information leading to the conviction of her killer.


FOLLOW THE GROUP ON FACEBOOK


“I have a hard time with the fact that there are no witnesses,” Smith said. “Where she was found was not an easy spot to get to.”  

With no word from law enforcement or any new clues, for now, a little girl’s killer is getting away with murder.

“Until law enforcement comes and tells us otherwise, Nevaeh’s murderer is still out there. And my family didn’t, in a million years, think that we would ever go through something like this,” Nash said. “It happened to us; It can happen to you, too.”

If you have any information about what happened to Nevaeh Buchanan please contact the task force at 734-457-6713.

Follow WTOL:  

Download our app here

Copyright 2016 WTOL. All rights reserved.

Powered by Frankly