3 men, 2 ex-officers, charged in KY cold case murder - Toledo News Now, News, Weather, Sports, Toledo, OH

3 men, 2 ex-officers, charged in KY cold case murder

Edward Carter Edward Carter
Leslie Duncan Leslie Duncan
Frank Black Frank Black
OAK GROVE, KY (WSMV) -

Two former police officers were jailed on $1 million bond in connection to a 1994 murder case in Oak Grove, KY.

On Friday, a Christian County Grand Jury indicted former Oak Grove policeman Edward T. Carter, 43, on two counts of murder.  Another former lawman, Leslie Duncan, 50, was indicted on two counts of complicity to murder.

A third suspect, Frank J. Black Jr., 39, was also charged on two counts of murder.

All of the charges stem from the shooting and stabbing deaths of Gloria Ross and Candida Belt.

The women were killed at the New Life Massage parlor in 1994.

Three years after the murders, former madam Tammy Papler accused Carter and Duncan of extortion and murder at a city council meeting.

"They weren't getting any more money from us, and they knew we had stuff on them," Papler said during a 1997 interview with Channel 4 News.  "The only way to keep us quiet is to kill the girls and put us in jail."

According to Kentucky State Police, Duncan is serving a three-year sentence at the Christian County jail for tampering with physical evidence in reference to the investigation.

Early Saturday, Black was jailed in Etowah County, Alabama.  Carter, according to state police, was arrested in Warren County, Ohio.

Both men will face arraignment after they are extradited to Kentucky.

There was no immediate information available on what led up to Friday's indictment.  The Oak Grove Police Department did not immediately issue a statement.

Copyright 2013 WSMV (Meredith Corporation). All rights reserved.

  • Headlines from Lucas, Wood, Ottawa, Fulton & Monroe CountiesNewsMore>>

  • Supporters of the Affordable Care Act rally against possible repeal

    Supporters of the Affordable Care Act rally against possible repeal

    Friday, March 24 2017 12:12 AM EDT2017-03-24 04:12:04 GMT
    (Source: WTOL)(Source: WTOL)

    It's been seven years since President Barack Obama signed the Affordable Care Act into law. And for those affected or simply in support of the law, that was something worth celebrating.

    More >>

    It's been seven years since President Barack Obama signed the Affordable Care Act into law. And for those affected or simply in support of the law, that was something worth celebrating.

    More >>
  • First Alert Forecast: Temperatures to soar on Friday!

    First Alert Forecast: Temperatures to soar on Friday!

    (Source: WTOL)(Source: WTOL)

    Temperatures will soar into the low 70s on Friday. 

    More >>

    Temperatures will soar into the low 70s on Friday. 

    More >>
  • Toledo announces precautionary boil advisory due to malfunction

    Toledo announces precautionary boil advisory due to malfunction

    Thursday, March 23 2017 11:27 PM EDT2017-03-24 03:27:51 GMT
    (Source: AP Images)(Source: AP Images)

    An electrical malfunction in the High Service Pumping Station at Collins Park Water Treatment Plant resulted in uneven water pressure throughout the system this afternoon, according to Toledo city officials. 

    More >>

    An electrical malfunction in the High Service Pumping Station at Collins Park Water Treatment Plant resulted in uneven water pressure throughout the system this afternoon, according to Toledo city officials. 

    More >>
Powered by Frankly