Suspect in Clarke-Straub murders back in court - News, Weather, Sports, Toledo, OH

Suspect in Clarke-Straub murders back in court

Cameo Pettaway appeared in Lucas County Common Pleas court Monday for a competency hearing. Cameo Pettaway appeared in Lucas County Common Pleas court Monday for a competency hearing.

TOLEDO, OH (Toledo News Now) - Cameo Pettaway faced a judge in Lucas County Common Pleas court Monday for a competency hearing.

He is one of two suspects charged with the double murder of Johnny Clarke and Lisa Straub in Springfield Township back in January 2011. The couple was found inside the home of Straub's parents with their hands bound with duct tape and heads covered with bags.

The hearing was to determine if Pettaway, 23, has the mental capacity to face the death penalty if convicted.

Pettaway and a second defendant, Samuel Williams, are facing aggravated murder charges.

There was no decision in Monday's hearing. The judge will rule whether a death penalty specification on the charges can stand Tuesday afternoon. By law, individuals who are mentally challenged cannot face the death penalty.

The defense's witness, psychologist John Fabian, took the stand late Monday morning. Fabian presented a lengthy report revealing a series of tests he conducted on Pettaway. He testified that he believes Pettaway is mentally retarded.

The prosecution's expert was psychologist Dr. Charlene Cassell, who disagreed and testified that Pettaway is not mentally challenged, but does have an antisocial personality disorder.

Even if the specification is removed, trials for both Pettaway and Williams are scheduled to begin later this week with opening statements Friday following jury selection. Testimony in the trials could begin next week. They will both run simultaneously.

Copyright 2012 Toledo News Now. All rights reserved.

  • Headlines from Lucas, Wood, Ottawa, Fulton & Monroe CountiesNewsMore>>

  • Man accused of sucking toes appears in court

    Man accused of sucking toes appears in court

    Friday, April 20 2018 5:55 PM EDT2018-04-20 21:55:19 GMT
    (Source: WTOL)(Source: WTOL)
    (Source: WTOL)(Source: WTOL)
    A man accused of sucking a woman's toes without her permission had a brief appearance in court Friday. Prosecutors claim Joseph Jones assaulted the woman inside a Meijer store in Bowling Green, last spring. Jones will  be back in court in July 13th for a pretrial hearing and his trial date is set for late august. In August of 2017, a judge found Jones  guilty of a similar crime in Toledo. He already served his time in that case. Follow WTOL:   Download our app...More >>
    A man accused of sucking a woman's toes without her permission had a brief appearance in court Friday. Prosecutors claim Joseph Jones assaulted the woman inside a Meijer store in Bowling Green, last spring. Jones will  be back in court in July 13th for a pretrial hearing and his trial date is set for late august. In August of 2017, a judge found Jones  guilty of a similar crime in Toledo. He already served his time in that case. Follow WTOL:   Download our app...More >>
  • Local business owner reacts to brick and mortar stores closing

    Local business owner reacts to brick and mortar stores closing

    Friday, April 20 2018 5:27 PM EDT2018-04-20 21:27:22 GMT
    (Source: WTOL)(Source: WTOL)
    (Source: WTOL)(Source: WTOL)

    We told you earlier this week, Elder Beerman stores and all others under the Bon-Ton parent company will soon close. It's the latest in a string of brick and mortar stores either shutting down, or in serious trouble. Is it enough to worry local, small business owners? WTOL 11 stopped by Lily's at Levis, Friday afternoon. The store was fairly busy. Lynda and Rod Brown of Defiance were among the shoppers looking for good finds for their home an...

    More >>

    We told you earlier this week, Elder Beerman stores and all others under the Bon-Ton parent company will soon close. It's the latest in a string of brick and mortar stores either shutting down, or in serious trouble. Is it enough to worry local, small business owners? WTOL 11 stopped by Lily's at Levis, Friday afternoon. The stor

    More >>
  • Toledo celebrates Rogers High School girls' basketball team with downtown parade

    Toledo celebrates Rogers High School girls' basketball team with downtown parade

    Friday, April 20 2018 5:04 PM EDT2018-04-20 21:04:05 GMT
    (Source: WTOL)(Source: WTOL)
    (Source: WTOL)(Source: WTOL)
    The city of Toledo is honoring the Rogers High School girls' basketball team Saturday afternoon. The Lady Rams made history this year when they won the Division II state championship. The team will be honored with a parade downtown which starts at 11 a.m. It will start on north St. Clair Street and go to Jackson, then onto Summit Street and end at Promenade Park. There will be a 30-minute rally in the park and Mayor Wade Kapszukiewicz will present the team with the key to...More >>
    The city of Toledo is honoring the Rogers High School girls' basketball team Saturday afternoon. The Lady Rams made history this year when they won the Division II state championship. The team will be honored with a parade downtown which starts at 11 a.m. It will start on north St. Clair Street and go to Jackson, then onto Summit Street and end at Promenade Park. There will be a 30-minute rally in the park and Mayor Wade Kapszukiewicz will present the team with the key to...More >>
Powered by Frankly